Behavioural Modification In Custody: Token Economy
Behaviour modification is a rehabilitation technique based on the behaviourist approach. The aim is to increase desirable behaviours and reduce undesirable behaviours through the principles of operant conditioning.
Token Economy
A token economy is a behaviour modification programme that rewards prisoners for displaying desirable behaviours. Examples include:
- Following prison rules
- Cooperating with prison staff
- Keeping cells clean and tidy
- Participating in education or training programmes
- Avoiding aggression and conflict
When prisoners display these desirable behaviours, they receive tokens. These tokens act as secondary reinforcers because they can later be exchanged for rewards, known as primary reinforcers, such as:
- Extra recreational activities
- Additional visits
- Phone calls to family members
- Access to preferred items or privileges
This process uses positive reinforcement, as desirable behaviour is strengthened through the addition of a reward.
Token economy systems focus primarily on rewarding positive behaviour rather than punishing negative behaviour. However, undesirable behaviour may sometimes result in the loss of privileges.
For a token economy to be effective:
- Desirable behaviours must be clearly defined.
- Rewards must be meaningful to prisoners.
- Staff must apply the system consistently.
- Prisoners must understand how tokens are earned and exchanged.
Because prison staff observe prisoners regularly, behaviour can be monitored and reinforcement can be delivered immediately, making prisons a suitable environment for token economy programmes.
Supporting Research: Hobbs and Holt (1976)
Hobbs and Holt introduced a token economy programme within three units of a juvenile correctional institution, while a fourth unit acted as a control group.
They found significantly higher levels of positive behaviour in the token economy units compared to the control group. This suggests that token economy programmes can successfully increase desirable behaviour in institutional settings.
Evaluation of Token Economy Programmes
Strength: Research Support
Hobbs and Holt (1976) found that young offenders receiving token economy treatment displayed significantly more positive behaviour than offenders in a control group.
This provides support for the effectiveness of token economy programmes and suggests that behaviour can be modified through reinforcement.

Strength: Practical Application
Token economies are relatively easy to implement within institutional settings such as prisons. Unlike therapies such as CBT or Anger Management, they do not require highly specialised therapeutic training.
This makes them a practical and cost-effective way of encouraging desirable behaviour across large numbers of prisoners.
Strength: Flexible and Adaptable
Different rewards can be used for different prisoners.
For example:
- One prisoner may be motivated by additional family contact.
- Another may value recreational opportunities.
- Another may prefer access to educational activities.
Tailoring rewards to individual needs may improve the effectiveness of the programme.
Strength: Supports Rehabilitation
Token economies are based on the assumption that undesirable behaviours can be reduced and prosocial behaviours can be learned.
This supports the idea that offenders can be rehabilitated and may help create a more positive prison environment.
Weakness: Behaviour May Not Reflect Genuine Rehabilitation
One criticism is that token economies may change outward behaviour without changing the offender’s underlying attitudes, beliefs or values.
Prisoners may simply behave appropriately in order to earn rewards rather than because they have genuinely developed more prosocial attitudes.
Therefore, behaviour change may be superficial rather than representing true rehabilitation.
Weakness: Effects May Not Last After Release
Token economies rely on reinforcement being available.
Once prisoners leave prison, the token system is removed and desirable behaviours may no longer be rewarded.
As a result, positive behavioural changes achieved in prison may not be maintained in the long term, potentially leading to reoffending.
Weakness: Difficult to Implement Consistently
For a token economy to be effective, all prison staff must apply the rules consistently.
In practice, this can be difficult because:
- Different staff may judge behaviour differently.
- Some prisoners may receive rewards more frequently than others.
- Inconsistent application can reduce the effectiveness of the programme.
Weakness: Individual Differences
Not all prisoners are motivated by the same rewards.
A reward that motivates one prisoner may have little value for another. Therefore, a standardised token economy may not be equally effective for all offenders.
Creating individualised reinforcement programmes may be difficult in prisons due to limited time, staffing and resources.
Weakness: Alternative Explanations
Any behavioural improvements observed may not be entirely due to the token economy itself.
Prisoners receiving token economy treatment often receive:
- Greater monitoring
- More staff interaction
- Clearer behavioural expectations
It may therefore be these factors, rather than the tokens themselves, that produce improvements in behaviour.
This makes it difficult to establish a clear cause-and-effect relationship.
Weakness: Ethical Issues
Token economy programmes give staff considerable control over access to privileges.
Some psychologists argue that this creates ethical concerns because prisoners may feel pressured to comply with behavioural demands in order to obtain rewards.
Although ethical concerns are generally less severe in prisons than in psychiatric hospitals, the use of rewards and privileges to control behaviour remains controversial.
Restorative Justice
Restorative Justice (RJ) is a method of dealing with crime that focuses on repairing the harm caused by offending behaviour. It aims to rebuild relationships between the offender, the victim, their families and the wider community.
Unlike traditional criminal justice systems, which focus primarily on the offence and punishment, restorative justice focuses on the harm caused to victims and how that harm can be repaired.
The offender is encouraged to take responsibility for their actions, understand the consequences of their behaviour and make amends where possible. At the same time, victims are given an opportunity to express how the crime affected them, ask questions and play an active role in the process.
However, restorative justice can sometimes be emotionally challenging, as discussing the offence may bring back distressing memories for victims and offenders.
Braithwaite (2004)
“Crime hurts, justice should heal.”
This statement captures the central aim of restorative justice: repairing harm rather than simply punishing offenders.
Key Features of Restorative Justice
- Focuses on offenders accepting responsibility for their actions.
- Encourages active involvement from all relevant parties.
- Aims to repair harm caused to victims and communities.
- Focuses on positive outcomes rather than punishment alone.
- Can take place before, during or after a criminal sentence.
- Not restricted to courtrooms.
Memory Aid: HEART
H = Heal and empower the victim
E = Empathise with the victim
A = Active involvement from all parties
R = Rehabilitate rather than simply punish
T = Taking responsibility for the crime
Alternative Memory Aid: RERERE
- R = Responsibility accepted by offender
- E = Empathise with victim
- R = Remorse shown by offender
- E = Everyone involved in the process
- R = Rehabilitate rather than punish
- E = Empower the victim
Forms of Restorative Justice
Restorative justice can take a variety of forms depending on the needs of the victim and offender.
1. Face-to-Face Meetings
The victim and offender meet directly to discuss the offence and its consequences.
2. Direct Mediation
The victim and offender meet with the support of a trained mediator who helps facilitate discussion and ensure that everyone feels safe and supported.
3. Indirect Mediation
The victim and offender do not meet directly. Instead, communication is passed between them through a trained mediator.
This flexibility allows restorative justice programmes to be adapted to the needs of individual participants.
Supporting Research: Sherman and Strang (2007)
Sherman and Strang reviewed 36 studies comparing offenders who had participated in restorative justice programmes with those who had not.
Findings
- Restorative justice reduced reoffending in many cases.
- It appeared to be particularly effective for violent offences and property offences such as burglary.
- Victims generally reported high levels of satisfaction.
- Victims often experienced reduced anger and anxiety following the process.
- Restorative justice was especially effective with some young and first-time offenders.
Conclusion
Sherman and Strang concluded that there was considerable evidence supporting the wider use of restorative justice programmes.
Evaluation of Restorative Justice
Strength: Individualised Approach
A major strength of restorative justice is that it can be adapted to meet the needs of both offenders and victims.
For example:
- Some participants may benefit from face-to-face meetings.
- Others may prefer indirect mediation.
- Victims and offenders can identify personal goals they wish to achieve during the process.
This flexibility means restorative justice can be tailored to individual circumstances, potentially increasing its effectiveness.
Strength: Research Support
Sherman and Strang (2007)
Their review found evidence that restorative justice can reduce reoffending and improve victim outcomes.
Because their conclusions were based on a large number of studies, this increases confidence in the reliability of the findings.
This suggests restorative justice can be an effective method of reducing future offending while also helping victims recover.
Strength: High Victim Satisfaction
Strang et al. (2006)
Research found that victims who participated in restorative justice often reported greater satisfaction than victims using traditional criminal justice procedures.
This suggests restorative justice successfully achieves one of its key aims by giving victims a greater voice in the justice process.
Strength: Holistic Approach
Restorative justice focuses on both the victim and the offender rather than concentrating solely on punishment.
As a result, it seeks to:
- Repair relationships.
- Reduce reoffending.
- Meet victims’ emotional needs.
- Encourage offender rehabilitation.
This may make it more beneficial than approaches that focus exclusively on punishment.
Strength: Cost Effective
Shapland et al. (2007)
Shapland and colleagues estimated that every £1 spent on restorative justice could save approximately £8 through reductions in reoffending.
This suggests restorative justice may provide both social and economic benefits and therefore represents a useful investment.
Weakness: Requires Offender Cooperation
A major limitation is that restorative justice depends on offenders willingly participating and accepting responsibility for their actions.
If offenders:
- Refuse to take part,
- Show little genuine remorse,
- Or engage dishonestly,
the process is unlikely to be effective.
Therefore, restorative justice is not suitable for every offender.
Weakness: Not Appropriate for All Crimes
Restorative justice may not be suitable for offences involving significant power imbalances.
For example, Women’s Aid has expressed concerns about its use in cases of domestic abuse.
Victims may feel pressured to participate, and offenders may use apparent remorse to manipulate victims.
This suggests restorative justice cannot be safely or effectively applied to all offences.
Weakness: Risk of Further Emotional Harm
Although restorative justice aims to help victims, discussing an offence can be emotionally distressing.
Some victims may experience:
- Increased anxiety,
- Emotional upset,
- Re-traumatisation,
particularly when discussing serious or violent crimes.
This means restorative justice may not always have positive outcomes.
Weakness: Time and Resource Intensive
Successful restorative justice programmes require:
- Trained facilitators,
- Careful preparation,
- Risk assessments,
- Multiple meetings before mediation occurs.
As a result, restorative justice can be time-consuming and expensive to organise on a large scale.
Weakness: May Be Viewed as a Soft Option
Some members of the public view restorative justice as being too lenient because it focuses on repairing harm rather than punishment.
Critics argue that offenders may avoid what some people consider an appropriate level of punishment.
As a result, public confidence in the justice system may be reduced if restorative justice is perceived as replacing rather than complementing traditional punishments.
Anger Management
Many offenders have difficulties controlling their anger, which can result in aggressive and violent behaviour. Within prison environments, anger management programmes are used to reduce aggression and improve safety for both staff and inmates. Anger Management is a form of Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) that aims to change the way offenders think about situations, thereby changing how they behave.
Novaco (1975): Anger Management Programme
Novaco developed a three-stage programme designed to help offenders recognise, manage and control their anger.
1. Cognitive Preparation
The offender is encouraged to identify situations that trigger anger. Common triggers may include:
- Feeling ignored
- Being challenged or criticised
- Feeling treated unfairly
In this stage, offenders are encouraged to identify anger triggers and irrational thoughts e.g.
Trigger → Thought → Feeling → Behaviour
The offender is encouraged to evaluate and challenge those thoughts through empirical and logical dispute

Participants are also taught to recognise the physiological signs of anger, such as:
- Increased heart rate
- Muscle tension
- Sweating
- Feelings of agitation
By recognising these warning signs early, individuals can intervene before anger escalates into aggression.
2. Skill Acquisition
Participants learn cognitive and behavioural techniques to help them respond more appropriately when provoked.
These techniques include:
Cognitive Positive Self-Talk
Using internal statements such as:
- “Stay calm.”
- “Think before acting.”
- “I can handle this situation.”
This helps challenge aggressive thought patterns and reduce emotional arousal.
Behavioural Redirection
Learning alternative responses to anger, such as:
- Walking away from the situation
- Talking through the problem
- Participating in physical activity or sport
Relaxation Techniques
Learning methods to reduce physiological arousal, including:
- Deep breathing exercises
- Counting to ten
- Progressive muscle relaxation
These techniques help offenders maintain control over their emotional responses.

3. Application Practice
Participants practise their new skills in simulated situations that would normally provoke anger.
This is usually achieved through role play, where offenders rehearse using their coping strategies in realistic scenarios.
Successful use of the techniques is positively reinforced by the therapist. Through repeated practice, offenders are expected to develop automatic, non-aggressive responses when faced with real-life provocations.
Ireland (2000): Does Anger Management Work?
Ireland investigated the effectiveness of CALM (Controlling Anger and Learning to Manage It) programmes in prison populations.
Method
A natural experiment compared:
- 50 prisoners who had completed a CALM programme
- 37 prisoners who had not completed the programme (control group)
The groups were matched using:
- A cognitive behavioural interview
- The Wing Behavioural Checklist (WBC)
- A self-report anger questionnaire
Wing Behavioural Checklist (WBC)
Prison officers observed offenders for one week and rated 29 aggressive behaviours using:
- 0 = No evidence
- 1 = Some evidence
- 2 = A lot of evidence
Measures were collected before and after completion of the programme.
Findings
- 92% of offenders showed improvement on at least one measure of anger or aggression.
- 48% showed improvement on at least two measures.
- Prison officers generally rated participants as less aggressive after treatment.
- Participants also rated themselves as less angry following the programme.
- However, 8% deteriorated on two measures, suggesting the programme is not effective for everyone.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that anger management programmes can reduce anger and aggression in the short term. However, the study did not investigate whether improvements were maintained over time or whether participation reduced rates of reoffending.
Evaluation of Anger Management
Strengths
Research Support
Ireland (2000) found that 92% of offenders improved on at least one measure of anger and aggression following participation in a CALM programme.
Therefore, there is evidence that anger management can successfully reduce aggressive behaviour in offender populations.
Holistic Approach
Anger management addresses several aspects of aggressive behaviour simultaneously:
- Cognitive processes (thoughts)
- Behavioural responses (actions)
- Physiological arousal (emotions and bodily responses)
This may make treatment more effective because aggression is likely to have multiple underlying causes.
Targets Underlying Cognitive Processes
Unlike behaviourist approaches such as token economies, anger management attempts to change the thought processes that contribute to aggression rather than simply rewarding or punishing behaviour.
This may produce longer-lasting behavioural change because offenders learn skills they can continue to use outside prison.
Weaknesses
Limited Ecological Validity
Blackburn (1993) argued that role-play situations may not accurately recreate the emotional intensity of real-life conflicts.
Offenders know the situation is artificial and may behave differently than they would in a genuine confrontation.
As a result, success during role-play may not transfer to real-world situations, reducing the programme’s effectiveness.
Lack of Evidence for Long-Term Effectiveness
Although Ireland (2000) demonstrated short-term improvements in anger and aggression, the study did not assess whether these improvements reduced reoffending rates.
Therefore, it is difficult to determine whether anger management produces lasting behavioural change outside the prison environment.
Not Suitable for All Offenders
Anger management assumes that offending behaviour is linked to poor anger control.
However, many crimes are not motivated by anger, including:
- Fraud
- Cybercrime
- Theft
- Premeditated murder
Therefore, anger management is unlikely to be an appropriate treatment for all offenders and may only be effective for those whose criminal behaviour is driven by aggression.
Expensive and Time-Consuming
Anger management programmes require trained therapists and multiple treatment sessions, often lasting several weeks.
This makes them more costly and resource-intensive than behaviourist approaches such as token economies, which are generally easier to administer within prisons.