The jump from A to A* is not usually about knowing more evaluation points. It’s about evaluating in a more sophisticated way.
A students tend to write: Point → Evidence → Explain → Consequence → Challenge
A* students tend to write: Point → Evidence → Explain → Consequence → Qualification → Synthesis → Judgement
A* students spend less time identifying evaluation points and more time discussing how important the evaluation point actually is.
A* Move 1: Judge the Importance
A students identify strengths and weaknesses.
A* students discuss how important those strengths and weaknesses are.
Sentence Starters:
- However, the significance of this limitation may be overstated because…
- Whilst this is a weakness, its overall impact is limited because…
- This may be less problematic than it initially appears because…
- Arguably, this is one of the most significant strengths because…
Example:
A Student: Consequently, the findings may not generalise.
A* Student: Consequently, the findings may not generalise. However, this limitation may be less important because the primary aim of the research was to establish causal relationships rather than population validity.
A* Move 2: Weigh Two Arguments Against Each Other
Sentence Starters
- Although ___ is a limitation, this may be outweighed by…
- When weighing the evidence, the strength of ___ appears greater than…
- Whilst both arguments have merit…
- On balance…
Example: Although Loftus and Palmer’s study lacks ecological validity, this weakness may be outweighed by the high level of control achieved within the laboratory, which allowed a clear causal relationship to be established.
Notice that the student isn’t merely listing strengths and weaknesses. They are comparing them.
A* Move 3: Evaluate the Evaluation
Most students stop after giving supporting research. A* students evaluate the quality of that research.
Sentence Starters
- The credibility of this evidence is strengthened because…
- The usefulness of this evidence is reduced because…
- However, the supporting evidence itself may be limited by…
- Therefore, the evidence does not provide unequivocal support because…
Example: However, the supporting evidence was obtained using artificial experimental procedures, meaning the support for the theory may not be as convincing as it initially appears.
A* Move 4: Discuss Relative Explanatory Power – This is what top psychologists do.
Sentence Starters
- Whilst this theory explains ______ effectively, it struggles to account for ______.
- This explanation appears to provide a more comprehensive account because…
- This theory may explain part of the behaviour but not the entirety of it.
Example: Whilst the learning explanation successfully explains the acquisition of phobias, it is less successful at explaining why many individuals develop phobias without any obvious conditioning experience.
A* Move 5: Synthesis – This is probably the biggest jump from A to A*. A students compare two theories. A* students combine two theories.
Sentence Starters
- It may be most useful to view these explanations as complementary rather than competing.
- Both explanations may contribute to understanding behaviour because…
- An interactionist explanation may provide the most complete account because…
- Rather than viewing these theories as mutually exclusive…
Example: Rather than viewing the cognitive and biological explanations as competing accounts, it may be more accurate to view them as complementary because cognitive biases may arise from underlying neural mechanisms. Examiners absolutely love this!
A* Move 6: Hierarchical Evaluation – Not all AO3 points are equally important.
Sentence Starters
- This criticism ultimately raises a more fundamental issue because…
- A stronger criticism is that…
- Whilst this methodological issue is relevant, a larger concern is…
Example: Whilst cultural bias is relevant, a more fundamental criticism is that the theory lacks explanatory power because it cannot account for individual differences in behaviour.
A* Move 8: Explicit Judgement – Most students finish paragraphs. A* students finish arguments.
Sentence Starters
- Overall, this suggests that…
- On balance…
- Therefore, the evidence appears to indicate…
- Taken together…
- Ultimately…
Example: Overall, whilst the theory has limitations, the breadth of supporting evidence suggests it remains one of the most convincing explanations currently available.