Sentence Starters for PEECCs About Research (GRAVER)
Point:
A strength of this research is its high __________ (GRAVER).
A weakness of this research is its low __________ (GRAVER).
One methodological strength/weakness of this study is its __________.
Evidence: TOP TIP: Refer to a specific aspect of the study rather than making a general statement or describing the whole study.
For example, the researchers…
The study used…
Participants were…
The findings showed that…
For example, researchers investigated __________ by __________ and found __________.
Explain: (WHY?) Explain why your evidence demonstrates the GRAVER issue you identified.
This demonstrates high/low __________ because…
This suggests the study has good/poor __________ because…
This is likely to increase/decrease __________ because…
Therefore, this can be considered a strength/weakness because…
Explain Examples:
Reliability: This demonstrates high reliability because the procedure was standardised and could be replicated.
Generalisability: This demonstrates poor population validity because the sample consisted solely of…
Validity: This demonstrates low ecological validity because participants completed artificial tasks that may not reflect real-life behaviour.
Consequence: (SO WHAT?) TOP TIP: The consequence should answer: Why should we care about this strength or weakness? Explain why this matters.
As a result…
Consequently…
Therefore…
This means that…
Consequence Examples:
Generalisability: As a result, the findings may not generalise to other populations.
Reliability: Consequently, psychologists can be more confident that the findings are consistent.
Validity: Therefore, the findings may not accurately reflect behaviour in everyday life.
Challenge: A counterargument that prevents your evaluation from becoming one-sided
Option 1: Challenge the evaluation
However, this criticism may be less important because…
Nonetheless, the study still has value because…
Although this is a limitation, it is partially addressed by…
Option 2: Evaluate the evidence
However, the evidence used to support this argument may itself lack validity because…
However, the findings should be interpreted cautiously because…
Option 3: Add balance
In contrast, other evidence suggests…
Alternatively, the research may actually demonstrate…
A more balanced conclusion would be that…
Option 4: Further development
Furthermore, another strength/weakness of this research is…
This limitation is reduced because…
This strength is particularly important because…
Sentence Starters for PEECCs About Theories, Explanations and Approaches (SAUNDERS)
Point:
A strength of this theory is that there is supporting evidence for its claims.
A weakness of this theory is that there is evidence which challenges its claims.
A strength/weakness of this explanation is that it is __________ (SAUNDERS).
Evidence:
For example…
Evidence for this comes from…
Researchers investigated __________ and found…
Explain: (WHY?)
This supports/challenges the theory because…
This demonstrates __________ (SAUNDERS) because…
This can be interpreted as evidence for/against the explanation because…
Consequence Examples: (SO WHAT?)
Supporting Research
Consequently, this increases confidence in the theory because…
As a result, the theory may have useful practical applications such as…
Opposing Research
Consequently, this challenges the credibility of the explanation because…
Therefore, some aspects of the theory may require modification.
As a result, psychologists may need to consider alternative explanations.
Debates TOP TIP: The best challenge often discusses the opposite side of the debate.
Consequently, this may be seen as a strength because…
However, this could also be viewed as a weakness because…
TOP TIP: Avoid saying a theory is completely “proved” or completely “falsified”. Psychology evidence usually increases or decreases confidence in a theory rather than proving it right or wrong.
Challenge: A counterargument that prevents your evaluation from becoming one-sided
Supporting Research
However, the supporting research may lack validity because…
Nonetheless, there is additional evidence from __________ which strengthens this argument.
Opposing Research
However, the opposing evidence may have methodological limitations because…
Nonetheless, the theory can still explain…
Although some findings challenge the theory, substantial supporting evidence remains.
Alternative Explanations
An alternative explanation is…
Therefore, the original theory may not provide a complete explanation on its own.
Balanced Conclusion
A more balanced conclusion may be that both explanations contribute to our understanding because…
Rather than viewing the theory as incorrect, it may be more accurate to view it as incomplete.
Knowing the difference between the EXPLAIN, CONSEQUENCE & CHALLENGE for other evaluation arguments
Alternative Explanations
Explain: This provides an alternative explanation because…
Consequence: Consequently, the original theory may be incomplete because it fails to account for…
Challenge: However, the alternative explanation also has limitations because…
Therefore, it may be more appropriate to consider both explanations together.
Usefulness
Explain: This shows the theory is useful because…
Consequence: Therefore, the theory has practical applications, such as…
Challenge: However, usefulness does not necessarily mean the explanation is entirely accurate.
Some applications may be effective despite the theory being incomplete.
Debates (Reductionism, Holism, Determinism, Free Will, Idiographic, Nomothetic)
Explain: This can be considered reductionist because… This can be considered holistic because…
Consequence: A strength/weakness of this is…
Challenge: However, reductionism can also be beneficial because it allows researchers to isolate specific variables.
However, holistic explanations can sometimes be difficult to test scientifically.
Ethnocentrism
Explain: This theory may be ethnocentric because…
Consequence: Consequently, the findings may not apply equally across cultures.
Challenge: However, the theory may still accurately explain behaviour within the culture in which it was developed.
Furthermore, later cross-cultural research may support some aspects of the explanation.
Scientific Methods
Explain: This can be considered scientific because…
This demonstrates the use of objective, measurable methods because…
This theory generates testable hypotheses because…
Consequence: Consequently, the theory can be tested empirically, increasing confidence in its claims.
As a result, psychologists can gather objective evidence to support or challenge the explanation.
Challenge: However, some aspects of the theory may be difficult to test directly because…
Furthermore, human behaviour is often too complex to be fully investigated using scientific methods alone.
Gender Bias
Explain: This explanation may be gender biased because…
The evidence used to support the theory was gathered primarily from…
Consequence: Consequently, the findings may not generalise equally to males and females.
Challenge: However, later research involving both genders has demonstrated that…
Furthermore, the theory may still be useful when applied to the population it was originally developed from.
Social Sensitivity
Explain: This is socially sensitive because…
Consequence: Consequently, the findings may affect how particular groups are viewed or treated.
Challenge: However, socially sensitive research can also have important benefits. For example, it may help identify groups who require additional support or intervention.